That aside, widespread radiation would ruin significantly larger areas (nuclear test sites intentionally avoid areas and conditions that would allow the spread of fallout, whereas bombardment would not); destruction of numerous functions of society and common services would kill many more.
Whether some subset of humanity would survive or not, this at the very least seems like a scenario well worth preventing.
That aside, widespread radiation would ruin significantly larger areas (nuclear test sites intentionally avoid areas and conditions that would allow the spread of fallout, whereas bombardment would not); destruction of numerous functions of society and common services would kill many more.
Whether some subset of humanity would survive or not, this at the very least seems like a scenario well worth preventing.