Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I just worked on something similar at a hackathon this weekend with the Muse Headband, it was really fun. We used a support vector machine to maximize the "calmness" output of the band, which is some weighted sum of gamma and beta waves I believe.


"We used a support vector machine to maximize the "calmness" output of the band"

fyi, this doesn't make sense.


How so? We give it different variables and let it change them incrementally. Calmness is a 0.0 - 1.0 floating point output from the band.

This was custom-made by the way.


Depends on what exactly you did, but the SVM doesn't maximize calmness - it finds a maximally separating hyperplane that separates calm data from not-calm data. If you had real-time biofeedback then the person wearing the handband might have used the feedback to help them relax, but in that case they are the one maximizing calmness, not the SVM.


Ok. My only experience with SVMs was reading the wikipedia article a year ago. Our implementation evolved pretty organically and I only thought later that it was like a SVM. thanks for the info.


What you've worked on sounds much more scientific than OP.


I'm not sure if that's fair.

They (claim to) have [0] a bunch of PhDs, and have a page with the same kind of words on [1] as parent.

  [0] https://www.brain.fm/about  
  [1] https://www.brain.fm/#science


#credentials


Their man researcher has a PhD in Neuroscience and the lead guy has been researching and developing audio-neuro software for over 11 years.

https://www.transparentcorp.com/company/staff_details.php


Well, yes?!

Your implied complaint was that their work is not very scientific. The team having PhDs in neuroscience is irrelevant/unsatisfactory/bad?

What would you like to see? Would it have seemed more scientific to you if they'd done it at a hackathon?


Obviously irrelevant, which renders moot the other two questions that you asked me.

My point is that the work itself is what makes something scientific, not the workers' CVs (note the careful wording here; calling them researchers is another appeal to credentialism).

With that in mind, what would I like to see? You should be able to answer that one yourself now.


Is the Muse easy to hack? I was thinking of buying one to play with.


The hardest part of the weekend was getting real-time data through OSC. It's been done in Python and node before, but none of us were super proficient in getting data from the local server the scripts pushed to. This is the matlab library we eventually settled on: https://github.com/MuSAELab/muse_osc

I'd say it was pretty easy compared to Myo, but I wouldn't pay $300 for one. I'd use it again though if it was available for a weekend.


You can fiddle around with it connected to a PC pretty nicely in Python


I bought the Muse Headband to do something similar, but the headband sucks tbh


What was your problem with it? It's not very isolated from electrical noise, but it can be pretty good still.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: