Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes Yes Yes! There's the distinction of "Natural Elements" and I've always suspected that it was a somewhat temporal distinction. While I believe that the Periodic Table is a Universal Truth, "Natural" vs "Man-Made" elements always struck me as a Earthly way of looking at things. Not bad, just not the whole truth.


Just FYI the periodic table also doesn't tell the full story. Take a look at the isotope table:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Table_of_nuclides_(complete)


I really love the Isotope Table. I seem to remember having a chemistry teacher that mentioned something about the table being wonky or secretive. Total hearsay.

I like the periodic table because I could verify it. Isotopes? Not so much...


I don't think there's anything wonky about that table, it's just often not in the curriculum in high school, and teachers don't want to "confuse" students with material outside of the curriculum. But for me it greatly simplified understanding isotopes and radioactive decay.

And why would you think you couldn't verify it? All of the isotopes in the table were observed in a lab somewhere.


"it's just often not in the curriculum in high school"

I'm pretty sure that most high school science students have at least seen it before though.


The Isotope Table? I'm old and rural, but I didn't come across it in high school until I (an atypical geek) went looking for it specifically.


I just don't trust it when it comes to transuranic elements, I think that's what I was trying to say here.

Everyone talks about the 'island of stability' but I just can't find the evidence. Meanwhile there's Americium in my house! (smoke detectors)


It turns out it's even worse than that. Plutonium and other "non-natural" elements have been found naturally occurring on Earth [1]. All sorts are supposed to have existed historically at the Oklo natural nuclear reactor too [2]. Probably safer to call them transuranic elements.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium#Occurrence

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americium#Occurrence


When you say temporal, do you mean temporary?


Yes and no. Temporal as it relates to time.

Time that me, you and everyone that will ever know of us could possibly hope to escape? Nope.

Deep time? Yes. Temporary? Depends.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: