Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wouldn't the point where it becomes morally obligatory to do that be once Trump actually starts doing things that are comparable?

Right now we don't really know which of his promises he plans on actually keeping.



Yes,

When Trump suspends the constitution and starts a continental war with Mexico and Canada. And sends Six million Jews including his own daughter to be exterminated in gas chambers then we can compare him to Hitler.

Until such events unfold (I'm not holding my breath) entertaining people who make these ridiculous arguments is like a slow, self inflicted lobotomy.


We can go by his stated intentions to help determine where in the realm of possibility his future actions might play out. Mass deportations and a retreat on civil rights and equality are within that realm.


I'm not saying there's no chance he'll do those things. I'm saying that it's not certain enough to obligate people to not cooperate with him.

(Also, if the Holocaust had only consisted of mass deportations it wouldn't be nearly as bad or remembered. Have some perspective.)


> (Also, if the Holocaust had only consisted of mass deportations it wouldn't be nearly as bad or remembered. Have some perspective.)

We already tried this and have seen the results. We rounded up and deported more than a million Mexicans twice in our history. It is remembered, California apologized for their hand in it a couple of years ago.

Millions of families could be uprooted, torn apart and be left stranded without ID, possessions or money[1] and left to die[2]. Mothers, fathers, aunts, uncles, brothers, sisters, friends, neighbors, co-workers and classmates could disappear.

My perspective is that 'exactly as bad as the Holocaust' isn't the bar to pass to be a potential tragedy.

I didn't make a comparison to the Holocaust, but since we're there: deportation and mass ordered removal is part of what made the Holocaust a tragedy. It took years of deportations (of the traditional sense), forced relocations and imprisonment before people were shipped to the ovens in droves.

[1] http://immigrationimpact.com/2016/04/07/deported-immigrants-...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wetback#Consequences


I don't disagree, but I was responding to someone who did compare.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: