Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why would you need to play music at home while you're going to a store?

Also, activating Bluetooth is as frictionless as activating WiFi.



> Also, activating Bluetooth is as frictionless as activating WiFi.

Not in my experience. Bluetooth is functional, but it's hard to call it better.

* Connecting 2 people (phones) to one device is hardly supported.

* Those 2 people can't really manage a single playlist without special effort.

* Auto connecting to a bluetooth speaker when I walk in the house doesn't happen. It does with wifi.

* Connecting to the bluetooth speaker typically kicks off any other connection

* The issue of walking too far from the bluetooth speaker with the playing device still exists.

* Ever run the microwave while streaming audio over bluetooth? It doesn't work.

In my experience, bluetooth is better at one thing: streaming whatever audio from whatever app I want.


Because you aren't the only one enjoying the music at your home. The most annoying thing about being at a party where bluetooth audio is being used is when the person paired gets too far away from the speaker.


Configure a tablet in guided / single app mode for music playback. Trivial stuff.


That would be trivial, but the small change in experience diminishes the value. If I want music in my bedroom, I don't want to have to walk to my living room to get the tablet, and I don't want to install a tablet in every room with instructions for how to use with Spotify, Pandora, Amazon Music, Pocket Casts, Apple Music, our networked media SSD, etc. or where I happen to want to pull music from. I don't want to have extra devices everywhere that require their own cords and physical spaces.

Sonos allows my wife and I to simply play whatever music we want, wherever we want, with no hassle. And it sounds great.


If you've got a spare tablet laying around, I'll take it.


That's a fine solution if you have an extra one laying around. But I don't and I'm hesitant to buy a tablet just to drive a speaker.


Is it even more expensive to drive a regular speaker with a dedicated tablet than a Sonos speaker?


Yeah cost is definitely not going to be a reasonable factor wrt Sonos equipment comparison. I think the tablet being misplaced, broken or otherwise abused is more troublesome.


>Also, activating Bluetooth is as frictionless as activating WiFi.

Oh my, no. Activating bluetooth is so frustrating that Apple built a special chip to make it easier. That Sonos work over Wifi and not Bluetooth is the primary selling point.


You're hosting a party and you run out of something so you run to the store.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: