Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Maybe your employment contract states that anything you create is owned by your company so there is no code "outside of work." The question then becomes whether that is a contingency that has affected your passion or not.


As would be the case if you worked for some of the Bay Areas biggest names in tech.


I thought those contracts were not enforceable in CA? I'm most definitely not a lawyer tho, so I have little to back that up, but it's what I read in Joel Spolsky's answer here:

http://answers.onstartups.com/questions/19422/if-im-working-...


Generally they are not enforcable, but it doesn't stop folks like Google and Cisco from having them. And they are written with big letters in the front "THIS IS AN AT WILL ARRANGEMENT ..." which basically says they can fire you at any time for any reason and later "We own everything you do while you work for us."

Basically the message is "Sure work on your own projects and we will decide it's no longer in our best interest in employing you." and "If you do a side project and publish it or let it out in any way, we may decide its no longer in our best interest to employ you." I have heard stories of course but only have first hand knowledge of one person with whom Google decided to fire because they did some open source work they didn't like.

When I asked an employment attorney about these sorts of things his advice was that I could probably sue them and win but it was simpler and less expensive to just quit if I really wanted to work on other stuff.


> I have heard stories of course but only have first hand knowledge of one person with whom Google decided to fire because they did some open source work they didn't like.

Wow. That's quite a statement, I'm pretty sure there would be quite a few people that would like to see a bit more on that. Both from the perspective of having google as a future employer as well as to make sure you didn't make it up, it's quite a statement.


> just quit if I really wanted to work on other stuff

That, or publish the code under a pseudonym.


Maybe I'm misinterpreting. Are there really contracts that say that any code you write, even if it is unrelated to your work and off-hours is the property of the company you work for? If so, that sounds like a horrible arrangement. That would be like a chef making a sandwich for himself at lunch and having to give it to the restaurant where he works instead.


Yes there are. Big companies mainly, eg the News Corp contracts say that.


http://answers.onstartups.com/questions/19422/if-im-working-...

This is often referenced when a question like this comes up.


Or if you have a standard contract in Sweden


HP used to have that clause in '06 or so. I read through their agreement around that time.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: