Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Like this example here: https://playground.play.ht/listen/1554 which says:

> "Hi Mom, I need some help. Some guys hit me over the head and put me in a van, and they're saying they'll kill me if you don't wire money to this bank account."

top class.

EDIT this was about one page down on the "see what people are generating" page



My stepmother tells she has been getting this type of scam, minus the accurate voice, for years. About one a year.

I'm not sure she would have spotted the scam if it had sounded right.


On the bright side, it's not a very convincing rendition of a human.


I agree. That guy sounds very nonchalant for being in life-threatening distress.


not just that, he sounds remarkably computer-like

PS on the downvote: sorry if I did hurt someone's feelings, but it's the truth


Totally agree, this sounds awful


It doesn’t matter. Given enough time and progress, it will be indistinguishable.


I mean, it kind of does matter? Since the start of this thread was a post about the imminent threat that play.ht posed, an example of it not appearing very dangerous is on topic.

It’s very possible that some other voice cloning software will be the undoing of the fabric of society, not this particular website.


It could be this website in 12 months or a few years. Or someone else. Doesn’t matter.

To me your reaction is like dismissing version 1 of the iPhone as a nothingburger because it’s battery isn’t good enough to be practical at launch.


It could be like dismissing the iPhone 1. It could also be like dismissing the Nokia Lumia.

Either way an unconvincing audio file is an unconvincing audio file regardless of what other files may become possible in the future through any number of various platforms and software implementations.

In the same vein, it is prudent not to mix up the factual current state of things with possible futures.

I don’t see the purpose of panicking right now. Are you using this anxiety as motivation to design better audio fingerprinting solutions? Identifying bad actors and vulnerable groups? Educating people on how to avoid being manipulated by fake audio?

What does posting “I am scared of the future” online accomplish?


Damn that's a perfect example.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: