Some people find the mental model to be very confusing. I've been writing hooks for years so intuitively, the behavior has sunk in. But I still admit that it's mind bending to try and understand how it actually works. The original commenter is absolutely correct that it diverges from both functional and OOP, and while that's not necessarily a bad thing, it's reasonable for people to consider it a net negative.
There was an article I read, maybe 3-ish years ago, that explained it very well. It had you actually build a hook from scratch (not a custom hook, like actually implementing hook-like behavior into JavaScript). It was great. I just tried looking it up but couldn't find it, if anyone knows what I'm talking about please link here.
Any chance it was https://pomb.us/build-your-own-react/? You can't really have hooks without building an entire framework, because the framework has to have the preserve the execution context between renderings.
