Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What many of them are doing isn’t a legally protected form of protesting.

Free Palestine protesters have been shutting down roads with their protests, this is illegal.

Tesla protesters are vandalizing the vehicles of private citizens and burning down dealerships. This is also illegal, and due to its political goals, it seems to fit the textbook definition of terrorism.

> the calculated use of violence (or the threat of violence) against civilians in order to attain goals that are political or religious or ideological in nature; this is done through intimidation or coercion or instilling fear

Had we not spent years tolerating these illegal forms of protest, maybe people would remember these are in fact illegal, and wouldn’t be so emboldened to keep doing them.

If someone wants to protest, that is their right. If someone is protesting by infringing on the free movement of other people, or using intimidation and violence to stir up fear to get people to comply with their ideology… that crosses well established lines.



> Free Palestine protesters have been shutting down roads with their protests, this is illegal.

If someone does something illegal, they can be charged with a crime and the legal process (access to a lawyer, courts, etc). It's not complicated and should not have any exceptions.


You are taking large movements with at least tens of thousands of participants and cherry-picking actions of a few people, you are contributing to the free speech problem by making false associations.


If someone is breaking the law, they should be charged with a crime.

How are we at the point where that statement is a partisan issue?


Where are those who attempted a coup on Jan6 now?


Pardoned?

Do you think I support that?


Well, who did you vote for?


Neither, I've lived in the US but I'm not a citizen.

I would have voted Democrat given the privilege.


Most Tesla protests have been peaceful. There have been THOUSANDS of them the past few months in cities across the US. You’re cherry-picking the violent ones that get much louder reporting.


> Free Palestine protesters have been shutting down roads with their protests, this is illegal.

Yeah, and so? Is shutting down roads a "threat to US national security" and therefore warranting arrest without due process and green card revocation? The protesters should be charged with whatever city laws (certainly it's not a federal offense) they broke, and fined or whatever.


writing an oped isn't illegal. why is that grounds for being detained?


... Excuse me sir, could I interest you into what happened on January 6 of 2020?


That was also wrong and I thought it was horrible.


And then? In the end, who did you vote for? The attorney or the coupist?


They were rounded up, given due process, and locked away.

The coupist then got elected and freed his minions. The coupist is not giving the same dignity to these protesters, or even some american citizens who just look brown.

What's your point here?


2021*




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: