I realize it doesn't make any sense. It was working until it wasn't. I contacted customer service and they just gave me the steps on how to set up the domain from the documentation. Since I had already done that, and it appeared the settings were correct (since it was working for a while and I never changed it afterward). I didn't bother with it any more after that because it's not worth fighting GoDaddy over $15 or whatever, I'm just taking my business elsewhere.