Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The union lobbies for regulations that require you to apprentice under an existing master in order to enter the trade. The union's masters then purposely limit the number of apprentices they take to limit the supply of license holders. Since the slots are then valuable as a result of artificial scarcity, they get allocated on the basis of nepotism etc. You're not the nephew of anyone currently in the union so you don't get an apprenticeship.

Moreover, getting your own full license takes around a decade, during which time you're expected to work as an underling regardless of whether you already have the capacity to do the job yourself. So to the extent that anyone can get an apprenticeship without blood relations or graft, they expect someone who is willing to be stuck in an entry level position for that long even if they already have significant relevant experience from a related field, and then you get in the queue behind a million high school seniors and never get a slot.



Quite different from over here, as mentioned it is a plain membership.

Getting permission for jobs is required in many cases without any union having anything to do with it, you have to get them regardless.

Finalising high-school without going through trade school, or into university, meant jobs that only unqualified people get.


you're describing a pre-20th century guild, not a union


I've only known one person who went into a trade union but it almost perfectly describes his experience. Right down to having an uncle in the union already.


In the US because of the merger of the AFL and CIO into the current AFL-CIO, "unions" in the US mean both the industrial "worker's rights" style unions like the CIO had, as well as the "guild" style unions of the AFL for plumbers, carpenters, etc. that are mostly about limiting the number of people in the field to make sure salaries don't crash due to oversupply.


> are mostly about limiting the number of people in the field to make sure salaries don't crash due to oversupply.

Notice that this is equivalent to ensuring that they crash three times as hard for the people being excluded, because they all still need jobs but are now stuck competing for not just fewer but also lower skilled jobs, and on top of that then have to pay more for housing etc. because trade work is being artificially kept in undersupply.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: