Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Usually when people say stuff like this it translates to “the tax rate is slightly higher than [insert less desirable location here]” or "my marginal tax rate seems really high since I have a very high income"


> "my marginal tax rate seems really high since I have a very high income"

You can read my comment above. If it was only that... it is way more than that.

But hey, a high income is not a reason to overtax over 50% to anyone. That is crazy just based on the idea of "because they earn more" IMHO.


I don’t think your comment above did your argument a lot of favors.

~50% taxation rate is not even a particularly uncommon tax rate for top earners. Basically every developed country has that.

From 1932 to 1981 the top federal tax rate in the United States was over 60%, peaking above 90%.


Rape and murder is not uncommon either and I think we can agree it is not something desirable.


Ice cream is also not uncommon. Wait, what were we talking about again?


We were talking about the fact that:

> ~50% taxation rate is not even a particularly uncommon tax rate for top earners. Basically every developed country has that.

> From 1932 to 1981 the top federal tax rate in the United States was over 60%, peaking above 90%.

It sounded like you equate common = good or acceptable. I dispute that.

I replied that slavery is bad (abusive taxing can be seen as a way of slavery), independently of how much you earn. So I asked you if murder and rape are good just because they are common, to see if you would be able to link it to the fact that because that level of taxing is normalized, it is not ethical.

You clearly understood it. Instead of ackowledging that maybe it is not ethical, you started gaslighting.

But if it is ethical, explain to me under which justification you make taking things via coercion from people is a good thing, as if they belonged a different category. In which idea do you base that? Because I have a terrible difficulty understanding these things.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: