Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've always found that attitude of not promoting your own stuff annoying. If you took the time to write it and think about it, you should be proud of it! If you're just spamming, people will see it and vote accordingly.


Submitting your own stuff is fine. It's when you mechanically submit everything that appears on your site that we start having problems.


Sure, and I think the difference is pretty clear to most reasonable people. What I take issue with is the idea that self-promotion is "bad".


Except HN blocks that I guess...

At least I try to always make good submissions, and usually HN only let me submit twice every month...


I'm curious about the submission throttling that you have experienced. You have 4 submissions from the last month (last 30 days) and 9 submissions for the two previous months. What is being throttled?


I don't know, but I rarely can submit new stuff...

When I joined HN I submitted a lot, but suddenly I could not submit for two weeks, then sometimes I can submit twice or three times in a week, and then have to wait two weeks again...


curious why, though. If it's good, it'll be pushed upwards. If it's not it won't be.

Why does it matter who does the submitting?


It matters heaps - links submitted by community members with no affiliation to the source have been judged worthy for submission based purely on the content's merit.

Dailydot, extremetech, pcmag, geek, macobserver, betabeat, itworld, bostinno etc have collectively operated dozens of acounts to spam their own stuff, none of which met an actual community member's standards for submitting a story.

Individuals submitting their own blog posts and especially with success are usually so low volume they're not even noticeable unless they overdo it and inevitably get called out for it.


>Dailydot, extremetech, pcmag, geek, macobserver, betabeat, itworld, bostinno etc have

I prefer to say "could" instead of "have" unless you have definite evidence.


https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5567427

Plus dailydot are just getting started with the OP + 'sexyalterego'.


What do you mean "judged worthy of submission"?


A submission from a real user implies one of us thought the rest of us might like this. They judged it worth submitting.


So a one person difference?


Think about everything you see online and don't submit. It matters.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: