> Link maintenance is hard; the web doesn’t just automatically stay intact; it requires effort on your part.
This sounds all well and good in theory, but - commercially speaking - becomes very impractical for many businesses. I'd be really curious what the ROI would be on a more rigorous link maintenance practice. My general impression is that it's simply not worth it.
> I should switch it to Apache so that I can get a 404 page, but I haven't got round to doing that.[1]
Interesting comment from the OP, whom I suspect also recognizes (quite possibly like GitHub) that the time it takes to do this type of stuff hardly outweighs the benefit.
This may happen to be true for some businesses, but it's not necessarily true. Some toolsets may make it hard, which raises the I. Others make it easy or free, so people naturally do it. The smaller the I gets, the more likely a given R is worth it.
I also think it's easy to underestimate the R here. It's very hard to detect things like brand damage and lost leads, especially when somebody turns up on your site once, thinks you guys are chumps because of a bad first impression, and never comes back. Whereas the I is obvious, because the cost is all internal to the company.
The two factors, alas, reinforce one another. Link rot isn't an obvious problem when setting up a system, because nobody is linking in. By the time the problem becomes noticeable, the system is hard to change, making the cost of a fix high. And that trains people to treat link rot as unimportant, deepening the cycle.
This sounds all well and good in theory, but - commercially speaking - becomes very impractical for many businesses. I'd be really curious what the ROI would be on a more rigorous link maintenance practice. My general impression is that it's simply not worth it.
> I should switch it to Apache so that I can get a 404 page, but I haven't got round to doing that.[1]
Interesting comment from the OP, whom I suspect also recognizes (quite possibly like GitHub) that the time it takes to do this type of stuff hardly outweighs the benefit.
[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6495675