Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why on earth was this comment down voted?

You lay out the reasoning for your blog post in a succinct and plausible fashion.

One is free to assume, of course, that you're a tinfoil wearing paranoiac and disagree with your reasoning, but down voting such a comment, into which you actually expend the effort to explain your reasoning just seems so wrong, infantile and dumb.

Another trend I unfortunately observed recently where comments around the line of: "Don't link to this (the this being a blog entry by Andrew Sullivan, which is hardly controversial) since [paraphrased] it does not reflect the dogma of the HN politburo.

It's crap like that, which really devalues HN and I think that's a shame.



This sort of thing is par for the course. Especially in articles critical of Google or Apple, less so with articles critical of Microsoft. That's likely both a reflection of the number of people working for those companies that also frequent HN and the dedicated group of fanboys each has.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: