Agreeing on the provenance of the warming seems to be a red herring when we urgently need to figure out how climate change affects us. Which areas will be flooded, which areas will become inhabitable, will we be able to grow more food or less, how many more people can we expect to starve, how many jobs will be created and lost, how will it affect life expectancy? I realize such research is going on -- I'd like it to be promoted better. The world is already an inhospitable place for many people and we already don't respond well enough. Currently I don't see why we would respond any better if things get worse.